User Submitted Cryptid Sighting: Herrington Lake Creature
Name: Edgar Estes
Age: 67
Number of witnesses: 3
Location of sighting: Herrington Lake, Kentucky
Date of sighting: May 1976
What you believe the creature was: Unknown Creature
Message: “We were in the boat, it came up 15 ft away, looked like a whales back showing a foot above the water, pushing water. I casted my line and float and pulled it across its back, there was 5 foot of its back showing, moving slow, we all 3 said what is that, we started holding on the side of the boat. Its skin was grayish black, no scales, like a whale. I couldn't see a head or tail. It went down. This lasted about a minute. I had a camera in the storage of the boat but didn't think about it. I was stunned and thinking it might attack or turn the boat over. We were in a 15 ft fiberglass boat with a 33 hp outboard. We were fishing out from a deep cliff back. I'll never forget.”
Thank you Edgar for contacting us with your story! We here at The PBI absolutely love tales of lake “monster” sightings, and when they can link around to a creature we’ve actually talked about before, they become even better!
For those of you who might not be aware of what I am referring to, let me tell you. The creature in Lake Herrington that Edgar and his companions believe they witnessed in the lake back in 1976 is not just some random unknown beast, it actually has a name and has been seen many times before. You see, the creature we are talking about is known as The Herrington Lake Eel-Pig and its believed to have been spotted as far back as 1925. Many who believe in the Eel-Pig claim that after Kentucky Utilities flooded the tributary and built the dam which created Lake Herrington, a mysterious creature somehow got trapped inside and has been sporadically spotted ever since.
The Eel-Pig wasn’t really thought much of or taken seriously until 1972 when a University of Kentucky Professor spotted something odd swimming around his lake home on multiple occasions. When asked by a local newspaper if he believed that what he saw could truly be the monster and bring validity to the stories, he famously responded by saying, “it’s only a monster in the sense that one would call an alligator a monster if they had never seen one before.” After these 1972 sightings, many believed that the creature went dormant, but now, thanks to you Edgar, we know that isn’t the case!
Thank you again, Edgar, for sharing your sighting with us. It has now officially moved on from being just a strange story shared among those around you, to being a legitimate piece of a crazy puzzle involving one seriously odd creature!
-The Pine Barrens Institute
Image Credit: Trip Advisor
“…It was about 3 feet long and the body was light in color, sleek, about 5 - 6 inches in width, thick bodied with so many legs….”
“…Our tires skidded on a patch of black ice, and the car started sliding uncontrollably. With only two choices, my mom veered the car towards the cliff so we wouldn't go over the edge of the drop-off.”
“I slowed down and watched a large black cat walking away and slightly uphill. I saw the entire length of the body as well as the long tail that curled upwards towards the end. I remember thinking it must be huge to see it so clearly.”
“I have heard it flying around at night, landing on roofs, and watching me and my husband out in our backyard at night.”
“…He said it walked around the house for 2 hours while my grandmother was helping him with his injured back. When his parents came back home, the thing went for them…”
“The wings were of no bird, but more of a bat, but gigantic. I came inside the house as soon it made a turn because it scared me, my brain couldn’t even comprehend what it had just seen.”
“My dad went back with me to get my books and check it out, but it was no where to be found. I will never forget what I saw.”
“This was no normal dog or coyote or wolf, this was an entirely different creature that should be looked into.”
“I turn my head for a second to watch my dog, and when I look back, the black dog is gone.”
“It had the snub nose face of a vampire bat, but it's face resembled more of a gorilla almost. The overpass is illuminated underneath by street lights and when the beasts wings were up I could see it's veins through the membrane of it's wings…”
“I noticed something glowing in the road, like a small ball of light. Then the light started to move and shoot straight up the road. At first I thought I was just seeing things and maybe just a lightning bug but lightning bugs aren’t that big…”
“The movement behind my friend became more apparent and I watched as something ran out of the trees and into the light of the fire. It stopped right in the middle of the road, directly in the firelight, and it looked me right in the eyes. Standing on all fours it was almost as tall as our jeep…”
“…as soon as I saw those eyes, I knew they were abnormally large. They were far too big to be those of an animal, and they had a strange look about them that made me feel like it could read every secret I had hiding in my soul, almost as if it could read every single thing I was thinking…”
“…When it landed on a tree branch in the middle of one of the pine trees, it’s body was nearly twice that of the tree trunk…”
“Off to the right, I could see something running in the distance coming my way. At first, I thought it was a deer until I saw it getting closer. I slowed my truck down and stopped when I saw it heading toward my truck.”
“It was long and skinny, (about 4 feet long) and had a diameter of about 3 1/2 inches. It was cylindrical. It was covered in short brown fur. The "head" of this thing was an indented cone….”
“In high school, my creative writing teacher (I'll call him Mr. J) told us a strangely detailed story that he claimed was 100% accurate…”
“The creature was human-like in body structure yet extremely muscular. It was built like an NFL running back. Huge muscular legs, super-strong abdominal muscles, 8 pack, very broad shoulders, and huge biceps….”
“…Some were running past, some had stopped to graze. One looked right at me as it stood on the back legs. I estimate it to have been 2 1/2 to 3 foot high…”
“…The fallen tree was propped up at an angle, as it had fallen over another tree. I was on the lower angle and I heard a grunting sound. I looked up and saw a tall, hairy creature standing on the raised end of the tree…”
“Then I noticed that it had a trunk. Not a long trunk like an elephant, but a trunk that hung maybe half a foot down past the lower jaw. The whole end of the mouth was hidden by this trunk.”
“She said it was opaque in color, almost shadow like. The wings it had didn't flap, it was just gliding in the air. This thing had bright red glowing eyes, and she absolutely freaked. I remember her scream.”
“My family and I were about halfway through the 45-minute swim. My mom was swimming ahead, my sisters behind. I felt something a little bit like a hand grab onto my left foot. My natural and immediate response was to turn around and berate my older sister for trying to scare me, but when I did I saw that she was at least ten feet away and whatever had a hold of my foot was still there.”
“Never have I ever believed in mythological creatures - nevertheless a werewolf type creature. But we both feel strongly that this is what we both saw at different times without knowing about the other. We are very freaked out now and don't want to go outside at night.”
“…I was with mum and dad, we were returning from our summer house through Mělník to Prague and strange star appeared in the sky, where nothing such shall be. We have noticed it. Then it "came closer" and was fixed on us, we were more and more scared and anxious. It was so strange. We know aircrafts, technology around the Earth and possibilities of the physics. This seemed to be under intelligent control, did strong, sharp angular moves and was really like a hunter and we were the prey…”
“…we all 3 said what is that, we started holding on the side of the boat. Its skin was grayish black, no scales, like a whale. I couldn't see a head or tail. It went down. This lasted about a minute.”
“As I got to the sidewalk and before I turned right to go next door, I caught a glimpse of something just behind me in the eastern sky. I turned and looked and couldn't believe my eyes. There was this pterodactyl flying overhead! It was about the size of a Piper Cub airplane and it had a grayish-blue body with bat-like wings and had mixed reddish-brown areas on it….”
If you have a sighting to share or a piece of folklore to tell, make sure to get in touch and let us know! Remember: It’s your story, so why not share it in your own words!
tags / user submitted cryptid sighting, lake monster, herrington lake, kentucky, 1976
“…It then issued an aggressive warning stance lifting it's two FRONT LEGS off the siding of the house & swinging them around whilst opening it's front pincers wide then closing as if saying "Don't try ANYTHING!". It seemed quite upset that it had been seen...”